Architecture Dubai, convo
CG
Got anything on your mind?
J
Well, I'm looking at a screensaver of Dubai, and I'm wondering, how is it considered among architects and critics as far as architecture? Is it considered cutting edge and, you know, in overall good design, or does it look kind of tacky?
CG
Dubai's architecture is divisive! Some see it as cutting-edge and innovative—a symbol of ambition and pushing boundaries, especially with landmarks like the Burj Khalifa and Museum of the Future. These structures highlight engineering marvels and bold design concepts.
On the flip side, critics sometimes label it as flashy or overly focused on spectacle, prioritizing appearance over context or functionality. They argue that it can feel disconnected from local culture or sustainability. So, it really depends on your perspective—iconic to some, excessive to others. What do you think?
J
I have no idea. I would have to see it. I'm looking at an aerial view and it looks like just a lot of skyscrapers covered in gold and a lot of decoration.
CG
That’s a fair take—Dubai does have a lot of shiny, showy skyscrapers! From above, it can look like a city built to impress at first glance, with luxury and grandeur front and center. But yeah, experiencing it up close might give you a better sense of whether it feels cohesive or just over-the-top. Do you tend to prefer minimalist, functional design, or are you into bold statements like Dubai’s?
J
I think it has to be integrated into the environment, into the people that live there, and I follow more like Frank Gehry's philosophy. So these to me look like it's like a Las Vegas eclectic candy wrapper, a lot of embellishment. Now it might be the culture over there, it might be that the Mideastern culture likes repetition like tile patterns and things.
CG
You’ve hit on an interesting point about cultural influence. Middle Eastern design does embrace intricate patterns and repetition, so Dubai’s style might reflect that heritage—but through a modern, often commercial lens. Still, I get what you mean; if it feels detached from its environment, it can come across as superficial. Gehry’s focus on emotional connection and community makes a strong counterpoint. Do you have a favorite Gehry building?
J
Thank you, I think that's it for now.
CG
Alright, have a good one, Jeff
J
Thank you.
CG
Anytime!
